Wednesday, December 28, 2011

Final Thoughts

I really liked The Glass Menagerie. I've decided that I am glad it didn't have a clean, perfect "happy ending." I think the ending was realistic and very meaningful. It definitely got me thinking.

This play is obviously written to be about memory. I think overall the play is really centered around how each of the three main characters, Tom, Amanda, and Laura, have a really hard time living in the real world. None of them have a grip on reality whatsoever.

Tom spends his entire life getting caught up in other people's adventures at the movies. He longs for a different life, but even at the end when he goes off to live one, he fails to find the motivation to seek any true change or commitment. He remains the lonely poet he was in St. Louis and is haunted by the memory of the sister he left behind. Tom cannot accept reality any more than the rest of his family could. Tom's father ran away from his reality, too. Tom uses his illusions to escape from his real life. Amanda claims that he "lives in a dream," and she is absolutely right. Tom tries to escape St. Louis and succeeds, but doesn't apply himself enough to escape his dream world.

Amanda is perhaps the most detached from real life, though she believes she is the only one in the family that has accepted reality. She distracts herself by putting all her energy into her own social goals. She refuses to accept that she is not the privileged person she was in her past, and that she is very responsible for her own failure. She will not believe that Laura is in fact peculiar and that Tom will not become the successful worker she wants so badly for him to be. She clings to the idea that her life is going to change and that she is going to thrive as she did in her younger years, but she doesn't actually make any steps towards fixing her life herself. She hangs on to the memory of her husband, and blames him for her situation. She refuses to see life how it really is, and instead, tries to push her unrealistic wants upon her broken, peculiar children.

Laura's detachment from reality hits me the hardest. Because of her disability and shy nature, Laura has removed herself completely from reality. She is not active in her own life. She instead spends all of her time avoiding facing the real world in fear of rejection. She does this by obsessing over her glass collection. She has invented a pathetic and child-like attachment to these tiny glass figures. She herself is a lot like her collection-fragile and transparent. Laura, like her glass, is also very beautiful if looked at the right way. For example, when Jim sees Laura, he doesn't just see a broken, insecure cripple; he also sees a beautiful and different woman with lots to offer the world. When the unicorn's horn gets broken off and Laura expresses how she believes it will be more accepted now, I think Williams' was showing how Laura would have to be broken and hurt to fit in the real world. Laura gives Jim the broken unicorn, a tiny reminder of how he broke her, trying to make her more normal. Laura is too fragile to live in the real world. Her disability and her mother's extreme expectations have caused her to collapse in on her self. The only thing she can relate to anymore are her glass animals. She find comfort in her illusions because she is afraid of facing the real world. She can't survive in public because she believes she is so inferior. This is why she never completes high school or college. It breaks my heart that Laura cannot overcome her obstacles. Just when I thought Jim was going to save her from herself, he left, leaving her even more broken than before. Even though Jim claimed to see great beauty in Laura's peculiarity, in the end he was trying to make her more normal. This could have worked, perhaps, if he had not left her after persuading her to open up. This only made her want to fold in on herself further. I do hope that Jim's kindness somehow helps Laura. Her smile at the end of the play gives me hope that maybe he helped her by trying to thrust her into normalcy. Maybe, in time, she will find a way to fit into the real world. I do believe that this would be extremely hard living with her detached and disillusioned mother, after both her brother and father ran away from reality as well. The only thing Laura can cling to is her glass menagerie. Her separation from reality, I believe, is the most heartbreaking. I don't know if she'll ever find true happiness.

I think Jim can find his place in the world if he can learn to let go of his former glory and work towards a new life. He seems to have enough motivation to overcome his illusions and make his dreams his reality.

I really appreciated this play. I'd love to see it staged for the full effect. I appreciate that even though it is based on memory, it is realistic. The people are easy to relate to. I grew to care for each of them, and I am saddened by their tragic fates. This play made me think about how easy it is to live without really living-how humans often escape from the difficulties of real life, by building themselves a protective fort of illusions and dreams that separate them from reality. By the time this happens, these people are often too far gone to find the motivation to change and grow and instead accept their tragic fate. They become too comfortable and numb surrounded by their illusions to ever truly overcome the difficulties and cruelty that one must face in reality. I guess one could only really survive and find happiness in the real world if they face the pain and trouble head on. One must step out of their own way to see their own light and promise. One must work to make a life they want to live, rather than daydreaming about an artificial and elusive whisper of existence, fabricated to temporarily ease and comfort a tortured mind. The only way to become motivated to achieve the dreams we desire is to accept that though the world can be cruel and unfair, the only way to find true happiness and good fortune, is to break down the protective walls of illusion that we build, and face that we ourselves are the only ones responsible for shaping our own fates, and whether we succeed or fail, is completely up to us. Just like glass, humans can be easily shaped into beautiful forms, like the animals in Laura's glass menagerie, or be shattered by the slightest tap of bad fortune. It is up to us, I believe, to decide how our situation affects us, not the other way around.

Act 2; Scene 8

  • The evening is going extremely well when the lights go out. They light candles for illumination. Amanda starts scolding Tom for neglecting to pay the electric bill she asked him to take care of.
  • Amanda asks Jim to go check on Laura, who is still not feeling very well.
  • I really like Jim. He is so gentle and kind to Laura. I love the conversation between the two of them, even though it consists mostly of Jim talking. I liked seeing Laura warm up to Jim as the conversation went on.
  • Laura and Jim reminisce about high school once Jim realizes he knew Laura. Laura reveals that she was embarrassed of her leg in high school because the brace clumped loudly. Jim comforts her, saying he hardly heard the brace. Jim tries to convince Laura that everyone has problems and insecurities.
  • I love that Jim, so many years later, signs Laura's program. Jim is so sweet to Laura.
  • Jim asks Laura what she is doing now, and she answers honestly. She shows him her glass collection and lets him hold her favorite piece, a tiny unicorn. Jim says the unicorn must feel lonely because he is different. Laura explains that the unicorn gets along nicely with all the glass horses, even though it has a special horn. This reflects how Laura gets along in the world with her disability. Even though she is different, she can still get along just fine.
  • Jim helps Laura to dance with him, but accidentally breaks the tiny glass unicorn, leaving it without a horn. Jim feels terrible about it, but Laura doesn't make a big deal of it. Laura says that perhaps the unicorn will feel less freakish now without the horn.
  • Jim expresses his desire to give Laura some confidence. He doesn't want her to feel inferior to others just because she is different. He reveals that he thinks she is beautiful because of her differences. Jim and Laura kiss!
  • And just when I thought Jim and Laura might end up working out, Jim admits to being in love with another woman, his fiance, Betty. Laura gives Jim the unicorn.
  • Jim tells Amanda he has to leave early to pick up his fiance, Betty.
  • Laura and Amanda wish Jim happiness and good fortune and he leaves.
  • Amanda takes out her on Tom who leaves too.
  • I really like Amanda's last line: "Then go to the moon-you selfish dreamer!" It has quite an impact.
  • I appreciate that you can see Amanda and Laura interacting behind the gauze curtain during Tom's final speech. Laura smiles, showing that she isn't too devastated. I think Jim's kinda words really changed her outlook.
  • Tom finishes the play with a monologue describing his travels away from St. Louis. He admits that he can't stop thinking about his precious sister, Laura, no matter how far away he goes. He encourages Laura to blow out her candles because the world is lit by lightning. Laura blows out the candles still burning in the candelabrum. Tom bids the audience good-bye and the play ends.

Act 2; Scene 7

  • The scene opens with Tom giving some background on Mr. O'Conner, who went to high school with Tom. James O'Conner, referred to as Jim, was incredible successful in high school, but he seems to have lost his glow quite a bit since graduating. Jim knows of Tom's secret practice of sneaking off to a cabinet in the washroom in the warehouse to work on poems, and because of this, calls him "Shakespeare." Jim is Tom's only real friend at the warehouse. Because of Jim's kindness towards Tom, the other boys are the warehouse seemed to lose their hostility towards Tom. Tom knows that Jim and Laura knew each other in high school, but that Jim doesn't realize that Tom and Laura are related.
  • Laura is extremely nervous because of all the fuss Amanda is making. Laura looks very pretty. Amanda is fixing Laura's dress.
  • Laura is very impressed with how beautiful her mother looks in her old dress. Amanda reminisces about all the success she had in this dress when she was younger. Amanda often references the past because she used to be a lot happier and more successful than she is now. Amanda's melancholy memories are realistic. It is easy to feel for Amanda as the tragic hero of this story.
  • Laura finds out that the man coming over was her crush in high school, Jim. She becomes sick with worry and decides she cannot sit at the table if Jim is going to be there. Amanda refuses to entertain Laura's silliness. Amanda forces Laura to get the door for Tom and Jim. Laura manages to get through introductions, but still feels really sick.
  • Jim wants Tom to be able to obtain executive positions like he now can because of his night classes. Jim tells Tom that his boss is going to fire him if he doesn't shape up. Tom reveals that he plans to move and that he has paid his dues to the Union of Merchant Seamen instead of playing the electric light bill. Tom admits that he is just like his father.
  • I'm surprised that Tom would leave his family-especially his sister. I guess he finally wants to find his own adventures.
  • Amanda is quite chatty! I know this evening must mean a lot to her.
  • Amanda makes sure to put in a good work for Laura to Jim. She brags about Laura for being both pretty and domestic. Amanda talks about Laura and Tom's father and how he left.
  • Laura faints because of her nerves, but she is fine.
  • Amanda leads Tom and Jim in saying grace before supper.
  • I like Jim so far.
  • I have a bad feeling that things are not going to work out between Laura and Jim. I don't get the feeling that Tennessee Williams' is going to wrap up this play with a bow and give everyone a happy ending. I don't know if it will bother me one way or the other. I guess I'll see what happens!

Act 1; Scene 6


  • I like the way Tom relates the changes and adventure to the brief, deceptive rainbows of the disco ball that hung in the dance hall.
  • Tom and Amanda make wishes on the moon. Tom keeps his a secret. Amanda tells Tom she wished for success and happiness for her precious children.
  • Tom reveals that he has found a man to bring home for dinner for Laura. The man is to come the very next day, leaving Amanda with very little time to prepare. Despite Laura and Tom's protests, Amanda decides to make a fuss over getting the house ready for the dinner.
  • Tom tells Amanda that the man is James Delaney O'Conner, an Irish shipping clerk at the warehouse. Amanda continues to bother Tom about Mr. O'Conner's character and looks. Tom knows that Mr. O'Conner goes to night school to study radio engineering and public speaking. This impresses Amanda very much.
  • Tom has not told Mr. O'Conner about Laura.
  • Tom warms Amanda not to expect too much out of Laura because she is shy, crippled, and a little peculiar. Amanda refuses to see her daughter as odd in any way.
  • Amanda fetches Laura and encourages her to wish on the moon for "Happiness! And just a little bit of good fortune!"
  • Amanda's tenderness towards Laura is touching. She sees so much in Laura, despite her peculiar ways. She doesn't want Laura's disability to keep her from being happy and successful. She'd do anything to see Laura happy.
  • Tom doesn't want to hurt Laura more by making her face disappointment. He doesn't want Amanda to get her hopes up about Mr. O'Conner because Laura is certainly very different. Tom wants to see Laura happy, too. He is looking out for his sister. He is very protective of her.

Act 1; Scene 5



  • I love this line: "I'll rise-but I won't shine." -Tom (I'm gonna have to use that on my mom.)


  • Also this one: "Sticks and stones may break our bones, but the expression of Mr. Garfinkel's face won't harm us!" -Amanda


  • I was surprised that Tom was the first to apologize instead of his mother. He is gentle with her, showing he cares. Amanda also shows that she cares about each of her children and their futures. Right after their nice moments, Amanda goes right back to being naggy and Tom goes back to being difficult.


  • I enjoyed seeing Amanda really open up in this scene.


  • Laura is worried about Tom's happiness. She is very concerned with others' feelings.


  • Amanda asks Tom why he escapes to the movies so much. He explains that he is looking for adventure that he doesn't have in his own life.


  • Amanda asks Tom to try and find a nice young man for Laura at the warehouse. Tom is resistant at first, but eventually agrees to try. I'm sure the climax will be the man from the warehouse coming to meet Laura. Perhaps it will be Jim?


  • The scene ends with Amanda making another one of her phone calls to convince people to keep their subscriptions to magazines.



Act 1; Scene 4


  • "After each solemn boom of the bell in the tower he shakes a little toy noise-maker or rattle as if to express the tiny spasm of man in contrast to the sustained power and dignity of the Almighty." Genius.

  • I now know that Tom was telling the truth when he said he goes to the movies. He drinks like his father did.

  • Tom describes the pictures he saw at the movies and the big stage show he participated in twice. He talks about the magic scarf trick and gives the scarf he was given to Laura. He talks about the best trick being the one where the magician got out of a coffin without removing any of the nails that kept it shut. Tom relates the nailed-shut coffin to his situation. Tom asks how someone could ever get out of a coffin without removing a single nail, and his father's picture lights up as if in answer.

  • This scene helped to shed some light on Tom's mysterious nightlife. It also showed that he trusts his sister and enjoys talking to her. It shows Tom's constant desire to escape his situation.

Act 1; Scene 3


  • I think Williams' talent is shown best through Tom's monologues. I love how descriptive his lines are. The monologues aren't just brief updates on what is going on. They also show how poetic and insightful Tom can be. I like that the narrarator is part of the story. I like that Tom describes his sister's manner as "frightened" and "apologetic." I think those words are good for describing Laura.

  • I like Amanda's line that she uses multiple times during the phone calls-"You're just a Christian martyr."

  • Amanda just wants to help her children, but she can be so irritating. She is always nagging them about something-turning a lamp on, sitting up straight, etc. It must be hard to breathe around her. It is not surprising that both Tom and Amanda prefer to escape through their illusions rather than be present in the life they have with their mother. It is sad, though, because Amanda really does love both her children. She wants what is best for Tom and Laura, even though she may not have the most effective methods of steering them.

  • I like the difference between how Tom reacts to his mother's nagging and how Laura does. Tom fights back. Laura seems to sink in further on herself. Amanda makes Tom want to leave. She makes Laura want to become even more introverted and detached.

  • Even though Tom does fight Amanda on everything, he does help her out by providing money for the family. That shows that he still cares about his life with Amanda and Laura somewhat. I do believe he is going to completely crack soon, though. He'll probably leave just like his father did.

  • I ADORE the monologue that Tom gives at the end of this scene. I believe Matt Price did this monologue earlier this year. It is hysterical! Tom's explaination of where he goes each night is so creative and detailed. This monologue really shows how done Tom is with his situation. It is a great opportunity for Tom to show his anger mixed with his twisted sense of humor.

  • Laura is clearly hurt by her glass figures breaking.

  • I can tell Tom cares about his sister because he stops to help her with the broken glass. I bet Laura is the only reason he stays in St. Louis. He must really care about her.